We run FNOL, claims, SIU, subrogation, policy administration, and customer service for US carriers, MGAs, and TPAs. Dedicated US time zone pods built in 5 days. Pre committed CAT surge to 10x. 50 to 60% lower than in house.
Talent is leaving the industry, CAT events are getting bigger, and combined ratio pressure has not eased. The same three failure modes show up in every carrier conversation.
The US insurance sector is on track to lose around 400,000 workers by end of 2026. Half of current personnel will retire within 15 years. Industry turnover has jumped from the historical 8 to 9% to 12 to 15%. Recruiting cycles run 90 plus days. Training another 60 to 90.
Hurricane, hail, wildfire, freeze. Claims volume spikes 5 to 10x within 72 hours. In house teams cannot legally hire that fast. Subcontractors are spread thin and start charging surge premium right when you need them most.
A/R days stretching, LAE creeping, premium audit and prior auth backlogs. Each one adds basis points. In house cost will not come down without headcount cuts that the talent crisis makes impossible.
Same operating model whether you are a Top 25 carrier, a mid market MGA, or a TPA. Volume, lines of business, and SLAs change. The build does not.
Volume profile by line of business, SLA targets, current cost stack, system access, compliance requirements. 30 minute working session, signed scope on paper.
Dedicated pod assembled from background checked staff, trained on your playbook, your systems, and your QA standards. Account lead assigned. NDA and DPA signed.
24/7 if needed, weekly QA sampling, monthly business review against the KPIs we signed up for. Drift caught early and addressed in the open.
Pre committed surge activates within 72 hours. Capacity scales 5 to 10x. Pricing locked at contract, no emergency premium, no scramble.
The back office work that drives combined ratio, retention, and audit posture. Run end to end or as targeted lift outs by line of business.
First Notice of Loss intake, triage, coverage verification, adjuster routing, claim setup. 24/7 multi channel.
Third party recovery investigation, demand letters, negotiation, file management. Revenue positive work most carriers underinvest in.
Special Investigation Unit support, claimant identity verification (with Arbitrail Verify), red flag screening, ISO claim search, deposition support.
Endorsements, renewals, cancellations, certificates, mid term changes. The high volume admin work that defines P&C.
Pre bind data gathering, loss runs analysis, MVR pulls, risk grade setup, submission triage for MGAs and carriers.
Final premium audit, exposure verification, classification review, loss control report production.
Inbound and outbound policyholder support, billing, claims status, retention calls. 24/7 and bilingual.
Pre renewal outreach, retention saves, win back campaigns, payment recovery. Tied to renewal rate KPIs.
Shared offshore BPO is cheap but generic. Dedicated pods cost a touch more, but they learn your stack, your customers, and your standards instead of starting from zero each shift.
Use shared BPO for the easy 60 to 70% of generic work. Use us where the work needs to learn your standards.
System agnostic, multi state ready, US time zone overlap, audit ready by default.
Guidewire ClaimCenter and PolicyCenter, Duck Creek, Sapiens, Majesco, Vertafore, Applied Epic, AMS360, AS/400 and mainframe legacy.
Where adjuster licensing is mandated by state, our pods operate under your licensed supervisor’s authority. Scope documented at contract.
Multi region delivery (Luzon, Florida, Colombia, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam) means genuine 24/7 with US time zone overlap on demand.
English and Spanish at no premium. Tagalog, Mandarin, Bahasa, Vietnamese, Portuguese, French on request.
Sampled QA every week against your standards. Full business review every month against signed KPIs.
Every engagement has an Arbitrail account lead who owns delivery end to end. One name, one number, one source of truth.
Surge pricing locked at contract, capacity scales 5 to 10x in 72 hours. Hurricane season is a known unknown, not an emergency line item.
We work inside your perimeter on read only credentials wherever workflows allow. Edit access is documented and audited.
Policyholders see your brand on calls, emails, letters, and audit reports. Co branded mode available if you prefer.
The operational practices and controls that ship by default with every engagement. Pragmatic, documented, and contractually committed.
Three structural reasons US carriers, MGAs, and TPAs run with us instead of a generic shared BPO or stitched subcontractor stack.
Shared pools rotate staff, learn nothing, and start from zero each shift. Dedicated pods learn your specifications, your customers, and your playbook in week one and compound from there. Quality and cycle time both bend in your favour.
Hurricane, hail, wildfire, and freeze events are known unknowns. Capacity cannot be hired in the days CAT demands. Our surge pricing is pre committed: 5 to 10x scaling in 72 hours, on terms agreed up front. No emergency procurement, no surprise premium.
Multi region delivery (Luzon, Florida, Colombia, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam) for genuine 24/7 with US overlap. 50 to 60% lower than US in house. One Arbitrail SG contract instead of stitching three vendors. Account lead per engagement.
Catastrophe events are getting bigger, more frequent, and more expensive. Hurricane Ian in 2022 ran $112B. Hurricane Helene in 2024 spawned 60,000+ FNOL calls in 72 hours for one Top 10 carrier. The 2025 LA wildfire season generated five-figure claim counts in days. The carriers that come out of these events with brand and combined ratio intact are the ones whose surge plan was built before the storm warning, not during it.
Three structural shifts have made surge response materially harder over the last five years. First, in-house claims headcount has dropped: the 400,000-worker shortage projected through end of 2026 has hit claims operations particularly hard, with turnover above 12% and 90-plus day recruiting cycles for licensed adjusters. Second, customer expectations on cycle time are shorter: a five-day FNOL acknowledgment, acceptable in 2018, now triggers complaint volume and social media exposure. Third, regulators have tightened. Several state DOIs now publish post-CAT performance data publicly and use it to escalate market-conduct exams against carriers whose response lags.
The asymmetry is brutal. In-house teams cannot legally hire fast enough during a CAT event. Adjuster licensing alone takes 4 to 12 weeks per state. Subcontractors are spread thin and start charging surge premium right when you need them most. The carriers who pre-committed surge capacity at contract sign-off pay a known rate; the carriers who scrambled in the moment paid 2x to 3x.
Modeling CAT volume against your normal claim flow is the first step. The empirical pattern across recent storms: FNOL volume in the first 72 hours runs 5x to 10x the carrier’s normal daily intake for the affected lines (auto, homeowners, commercial property). Subsequent days taper but stay 2x to 4x for two to four weeks depending on event size. Total event volume can run 30x to 60x normal week, compressed into the first month.
The single most important contract clause: the surge rate is locked at contract signing, not at activation. This is the difference between paying a known $X per claim during a CAT event versus paying market spot rate when every other carrier is also bidding. Pre-committed capacity ranges from a 3x to 10x scaling guarantee within 72 hours, with contractual delivery SLAs and penalty clauses if missed. If your current BPO contract does not have this, your CAT plan is incomplete.
The first 24 hours after CAT impact are dominated by FNOL intake. Carriers that route 100% of FNOL through their normal channel get overwhelmed. Mature surge plans pre-build a load-shedding architecture: a primary FNOL channel (your own digital first or call center), a pre-committed BPO surge channel (which activates at threshold), and a tertiary IVR/digital fallback for the highest-volume hours. The shedding pattern is documented in the BPO contract and tested in tabletop exercises.
During CAT, most claims are predictable: standard auto comprehensive, property damage from named perils, common loss patterns. AI-augmented triage can sort 70% to 80% of incoming claims into pre-defined paths within minutes of FNOL, with the human adjusters focused on the 20% to 30% that are genuinely complex. This is where the AI-plus-human model materially outperforms either alone.
The surge does not end when volume normalizes. The tail of subrogation, supplement claims, supplemental damage discovered weeks later, and rate-of-recovery on closed claims runs for 6 to 18 months after a major CAT. Your surge plan needs to extend through this tail, not just the spike. Carriers that ramp surge capacity down too fast post-event end up under-resourced for the long-tail subrogation work that is actually revenue-positive.
"Provider commits to scale claims processing capacity by [5 to 10x] within 72 hours of activation notice from Carrier, at the rates and terms set forth in Annex A. No surge premium, additional fees, or rate adjustments shall apply during the surge period beyond those specified in Annex A. Failure to deliver committed capacity within the SLA period shall result in liquidated damages of $[X] per day per percentage point under-delivered."
Most BPO contracts default to a "best efforts" surge clause with rates "to be determined at the time of activation". This is a polite way of saying "we will charge whatever the market bears when you call us." For a Top 50 carrier, the difference between locked-rate surge and market-rate surge during a Hurricane Ian-scale event runs $5M to $20M in additional LAE. A pre-committed surge clause negotiated at contract sign-off, when you have leverage, costs nothing. A surge premium paid during activation, when you have no leverage, costs everything.
The carriers that get materially better at CAT response over time run a structured post-event review within 30 days of the event. The review covers: (1) FNOL channel performance vs SLA, (2) cycle time by claim type, (3) customer satisfaction by claimant cohort, (4) reserves accuracy at 30 days vs final, (5) BPO partner performance, (6) DOI complaint volume and resolution, (7) what would have improved the response. The output is a written playbook update that goes into the next CAT season’s preparation. This discipline is the difference between getting better and getting lucky.
Arbitrail’s Insurance BPO contracts include pre-committed CAT surge as a standard term. Capacity scales 5 to 10x within 72 hours of activation. Rates are locked at contract sign, not at activation. Liquidated-damages clauses for under-delivery are part of the standard MSA. Tabletop exercises are run quarterly during peak season for active engagements.
Bring your volume profile, your highest friction workstream, and the SLAs you commit to your business. We scope a POC against your KPIs in 30 minutes, run it for 15 days, and walk if we miss.
What carriers, MGAs, and TPAs ask before bringing Arbitrail in. Anything else, just email and we will answer the same day.
Send a message about Arbitrail Insurance, book a discovery call, or email us directly. We reply within 24 hours, weekdays.
If you know what you’re looking for, grab a slot on the calendar. No back-and-forth.
Open CalendlyBring your volume profile, your highest friction workstream, and the SLAs you commit to your business. We will scope a 15 day POC against your KPIs in 30 minutes.